Discussion IPL 2019 | Winner - Mumbai Indians

[Endgame]

I want KKR to win just so to spice up the points table

I want to see every lower ranked team winning every day.

 

[Jagadeesh]

You copy-pasted Wikipedia (for so-called law) and blamed me for defending myself!!!
For your kind information, Wikipedia statement isn't acceptable.
You may be wondering why this reply is after 1.5 days! I immediately checked at No ball | MCC but didn't found anything such there. Also Law 21.10 is
Ball bouncing over head height of striker
The umpire shall call and signal No ball for any delivery which, after pitching, passes or would have passed over head height of the striker standing upright at the popping crease.
Since nothing was mentioned about waist high, I was about to ask you for source. But since I was travelling at that time, trusted yours (thinking you might get it from some reliable/official source). Never thought your official source is Wikipedia!!!!!!

If you want reliable source about my stand here's the 'Reliable' source (Former umpire Hariharan):
"Let's get this straight. As per ICC playing conditions, it was square leg umpire Bruce Oxenford's prerogative to check waist high full toss. Umpire Gandhe had no business signalling no ball. He got it wrong.

"Now coming to commentators and experts. No umpire can go upstairs to check for validity of a no ball if the batsman is not out (@Sarkar bro). So, umpires couldn't have referred it to TV umpire," said Hariharan.

"Lastly, Mahendra Singh Dhoni had no business entering the ground as that is completely prohibited. For starters, the 50 percent fine is a very light sanction," said Hariharan.
IPL 2019: 50 per cent match fee fine is kid-gloving MS Dhoni, says Bishan Bedi

Now tell me bro, why actions shouldn't be taken against you for deliberate falsifying, misdirection and accusing a moderator?

I Never Copied From Wikipedia And I Stand That My Statement Is 100% Correct. But I Took That From MCC's Law Book For Umpire's Exam. Stop Finding Loop Holes To Tackle Others. Learn To Accept Your Mistakes. Life Will Be More Good. I Thought You Forgot About The Issue. But You Are Again Starting. BTW, This Attitude Is Not Good For A Moderator And For Your Life Also. Cheers.

 

[ABCDEFGH]

I want to see every lower ranked team winning every day.

Will be fun, even a team with 7 wins might easily qualify.

Infact last year MI could have qualified with 7 wins.

 

[TushShar]

Will be fun, even a team with 7 wins might easily qualify.

Infact last year MI could have qualified with 7 wins.

Last year RR qualified with 14 points as well

 

[Siva]

I Never Copied From Wikipedia And I Stand That My Statement Is 100% Correct. But I Took That From MCC's Law Book For Umpire's Exam. Stop Finding Loop Holes To Tackle Others. Learn To Accept Your Mistakes. Life Will Be More Good. I Thought You Forgot About The Issue. But You Are Again Starting. BTW, This Attitude Is Not Good For A Moderator And For Your Life Also. Cheers.

Can you please post a proper source apart from Wikipedia?

 

[TushShar]

Now what I want to see is that till every team reaches 11 matches then nobody goes ahead by 14 points and nobody stays below 8 points..It will make things exciting..

Hence,sorry to say but I want CSK to lose and SRH to win to spice up things

 

[ABCDEFGH]

Last year RR qualified with 14 points as well

So atleast once they qualified with 14 points.

*Remembers that epic 2014 match between Mi vs RR*
Rahul Dravid threw away his cap in anger (mumbai Indians vs Rajasthan royals) on Make a GIF

 

[Jagadeesh]

Can you please post a proper source apart from Wikipedia?

"Bouncers going over the batsman's head (standing upright) are no-balls. Repeated legal bouncers likely to cause injury can also be called no-balls. Fast full tosses or beamers passing above waist height (defined as the waist of the batsman, not the waist-band of the trousers). Slower deliveries passing over shoulder height are also no-balls. You can check the height with your colleague at square leg (if he's awake and not lost pondering how he got out first ball a few minutes earlier) but the square leg umpire should not make the call. Maybe more difficult is the distinction between "fast" and "slow" bowling; according to the professional umpires anyone who isn't a spinner should be regarded as "fast"; however even this isn't very satisfactory, so the umpire must use their judgement in the end." - Remantle Cricket Club Umpire's Note.

Which umpire should call a full toss a no ball? - Quora

BCCI Level 1 Umpire's Answer To A Quora Question - Posted 1 Year Ago.

It is the bowler's end umpire who shall call and signal no ball everytime a full pitched delivery is bowled (non pitching)(full toss).

I would like to continue further on this to give more clarity about this call, which I too had misunderstood before going through the complete laws of cricket as part of umpring certication.

We have seen on television that whenever above the waist non pitching delivery is bowled, the striker's end umpire extends his arm to signal the no ball. But what I said in the first paragraph is something really different. Isn't it.

Facts and Practices:

Like I mentioned earlier, it is the responsibility of bowler's end umpire to judge the height, to call and signal no ball.
What the striker's end umpire does is only to assist the bowler's end umpire in taking the right call.
What the striker's end umpire shows is only a soft signal (assisting signal) based on pre-match understanding between both umpires.
If bowler's end misses the height factor, he is always assisted by the striker's end umpire and the bowler's end umpire calls and signals no ball based on the assistance.
If bowler's end umpire has picked the height of the delivery, he can call and signal no ball eventhough there is no assisting signal from striker's end umpire.
Additional information:

Always judge the height of the delivery at the popping crease only and relative to batsman's height - standing upright in normal gaurd position. It remain same even if the striker steps out to play the ball or plays the ball going back deep in the crease.

@Siva Bro, Is This Fine..?

 

[Siva]

"Bouncers going over the batsman's head (standing upright) are no-balls. Repeated legal bouncers likely to cause injury can also be called no-balls. Fast full tosses or beamers passing above waist height (defined as the waist of the batsman, not the waist-band of the trousers). Slower deliveries passing over shoulder height are also no-balls. You can check the height with your colleague at square leg (if he's awake and not lost pondering how he got out first ball a few minutes earlier) but the square leg umpire should not make the call. Maybe more difficult is the distinction between "fast" and "slow" bowling; according to the professional umpires anyone who isn't a spinner should be regarded as "fast"; however even this isn't very satisfactory, so the umpire must use their judgement in the end." - Remantle Cricket Club Umpire's Note.

Which umpire should call a full toss a no ball? - Quora

BCCI Level 1 Umpire's Answer To A Quora Question - Posted 1 Year Ago.

It is the bowler's end umpire who shall call and signal no ball everytime a full pitched delivery is bowled (non pitching)(full toss).

I would like to continue further on this to give more clarity about this call, which I too had misunderstood before going through the complete laws of cricket as part of umpring certication.

We have seen on television that whenever above the waist non pitching delivery is bowled, the striker's end umpire extends his arm to signal the no ball. But what I said in the first paragraph is something really different. Isn't it.

Facts and Practices:

Like I mentioned earlier, it is the responsibility of bowler's end umpire to judge the height, to call and signal no ball.
What the striker's end umpire does is only to assist the bowler's end umpire in taking the right call.
What the striker's end umpire shows is only a soft signal (assisting signal) based on pre-match understanding between both umpires.
If bowler's end misses the height factor, he is always assisted by the striker's end umpire and the bowler's end umpire calls and signals no ball based on the assistance.
If bowler's end umpire has picked the height of the delivery, he can call and signal no ball eventhough there is no assisting signal from striker's end umpire.
Additional information:

Always judge the height of the delivery at the popping crease only and relative to batsman's height - standing upright in normal gaurd position. It remain same even if the striker steps out to play the ball or plays the ball going back deep in the crease.

@Siva Bro, Is This Fine..?

I'm sorry, we can't consider Quora as a source. I can also create a profile on Quora and say that I'm an umpire and write whatever I want as an answer. You quoted the rule number earlier. So please post an official link or pic that shows that rule.

 

[M.J.Sadiq]

Nobody hating RCB here unlike ur hating on MSD & CSK .. everything going smooth now but you desperately want to start the things again what u done in starting days of this IPL season in this thread

Next time Comment like this will report to team or will post in TTT Section So please take care


Regards

Bro , you cannot say no haters. Haters and lovers will always be there. So in my POV, this reply not required. And not sure why you are unnecessarily dragging CSK here. Sometimes, it is we who drag problems into our life.