Endgame
Member
- Joined
- 23 Jan 2016
- Messages
- 3,650
- Reaction score
- 4,993
For Your Kind Information,
MCC Law 21.10 :
"By default, it is the bowler's end umpire who calls and signals no-ball. When the judgement of ball height is required (for beamers and short balls), his colleague (the striker's end umpire) will assist him with a signal.
Either umpire may call a bowler for throwing, although the striker's end umpire is naturally better-placed, and so has the primary responsibility."
You copy-pasted Wikipedia (for so-called law) and blamed me for defending myself!!!Still, You Defend Your False View.
For your kind information, Wikipedia statement isn't acceptable.
You may be wondering why this reply is after 1.5 days! I immediately checked at No ball | MCC but didn't found anything such there. Also Law 21.10 is
Ball bouncing over head height of striker
The umpire shall call and signal No ball for any delivery which, after pitching, passes or would have passed over head height of the striker standing upright at the popping crease.
Since nothing was mentioned about waist high, I was about to ask you for source. But since I was travelling at that time, trusted yours (thinking you might get it from some reliable/official source). Never thought your official source is Wikipedia!!!!!!
If you want reliable source about my stand
here's the 'Reliable' source (Former umpire Hariharan):Straight umpire can't call no-ball (or wide) on height and leg-umpire can't call front foot no-ball or line-wide.
"Let's get this straight. As per ICC playing conditions, it was square leg umpire Bruce Oxenford's prerogative to check waist high full toss. Umpire Gandhe had no business signalling no ball. He got it wrong.
"Now coming to commentators and experts. No umpire can go upstairs to check for validity of a no ball if the batsman is not out (@Sarkar bro). So, umpires couldn't have referred it to TV umpire," said Hariharan.
"Lastly, Mahendra Singh Dhoni had no business entering the ground as that is completely prohibited. For starters, the 50 percent fine is a very light sanction," said Hariharan.
IPL 2019: 50 per cent match fee fine is kid-gloving MS Dhoni, says Bishan Bedi