Discussion IPL 2019 | Winner - Mumbai Indians

[Vadirocks]

Are you asking me or @Endgame? Did you quote my post by mistake?

Ha Ha Ha only You Bro

 

[Vadirocks]

Ok but so called international umpire(here ur degrading ur own country umpire) told it's not a no ball what abt that ?? What is ur view on that it's a no ball or not ??

At First Look It's Absolutely Looks Like No-Ball But Was Out Of The Crease

Need A Deep Analysis As Where He Was Standing? What If He Would Have Stood At Crease?

Can Someone Give Clear Picture Or Video?

 

[somnath chakraborty]

 

[Sarkar]

The difference is in cricket rules.
Straight umpire can't call no-ball (or wide) on height and leg-umpire can't call front foot no-ball or line-wide.
The international umpire immediately rectified his partner's mistake.

Understood but they could have gone to 3rd Umpire to check height specially when both are in disagreement, i am sure if it was caught then they would go just like Ind vs Ban WC match.

And what about Ban vs WI International match ? There Straight Umpie called no ball on legal delivery thinking overstepping and it was caught out but that out was denied and it happened twice on that same over

 

[Sai Jai]

But Why Biased Against A Particular Person/People

Oh God then u have to come from the 1st page of the thread I guess

Tamil film comedy dialogue

Ethu kalaatam naa othukamaatan illam kotaiyum aazhinga naa muthula erunthu varen

Marumpadiyum mothalaeruntha

Note: Simple Tamil film comedy dialogue can't give translation sorry

 

[Endgame]

I Don't Understand One Thing!

Those Who Have Blamed Ashwin For Mankading Incident - That Time Both The Umpires Were Acted As Per Law But Many Of Us Blamed Ashwin Only!

Now Issue With Umpire As Well As MSD - But Here We 95% People Blaming MSD Only!

We All Have Right To Criticize Anybody But Why Biased Against A Particular Person/People?

During Ashwin's 'run-out' incident, I supported him as everything was under the rules.
But players can't show descent (in fact, it's punishable) on umpiring decision. Even a small gesture lead to big punishment. Quite sure, if it was an international match, MS could be awarded much significant sanctions.

 

[Endgame]

Understood but they could have gone to 3rd Umpire to check height, i am ure if it was caught then they would go just like Ind vs Ban WC match. And what about Ban vs WI International match ? There Straight Umpie called no ball on legal delivery thinking overstepping and it was caught out but that out was denied and it happened twice on that same over

You're mixing umpiring mistakes/blunders with rules.

 

[Sai Jai]

At First Look It's Absolutely Looks Like No-Ball But Was Out Of The Crease

Need A Deep Analysis As Where He Was Standing? What If He Would Have Stood At Crease?

Can Someone Give Clear Picture Or Video?

Just checked in hotstar he hit the ball on standing bit outside the line

 

[Sarkar]

You're mixing umpiring mistakes/blunders with rules.

So what does rules say when umpire does a mistake ? Can he correct it by reversing his original decision ?

 

[Siva]

Straight umpire can't call no-ball (or wide) on height and leg-umpire can't call front foot no-ball or line-wide.

I think, in day before yesterday's match (Don't remember exactly which match), straight umpire called wide for height and the leg umpire was seen signaling one per over and not calling wide. Commentators pointed it out too. Umpiring had been of shocking standards in this year's IPL, despite having International umpires.