Discussion Premier League Season 2023-2024 | News, Discussion & Updates

[rohitvatsa]

Keeper shouldn't be coming outside the area to tackle a player. That's a straight up a red card offense.

There are 2 things to consider :1)whether City had covering defenders 2)Was the force of collision uncontrolled.
Referee and your's truly believes both conditions were not met,hence no red.

 

[somnath chakraborty]

2)Was the force of collision uncontrolled.

1st condition agree
2nd condition depends also on view of refree and metal of refree

 

[rohitvatsa]

1st condition agree
2nd condition depends also on view of refree and metal of refree

Would you give red for that tackle anywhere else on the field done by an outfielder?

 

[somnath chakraborty]

Would you give red for that tackle anywhere else on the field done by an outfielder?

Power was not in my house not saw match i said as in general but i feel gk offence is much higher than outfield olayers as gk have his box area and gk king of that place and if he infiltrate he should get punished

 

[rohitvatsa]

Power was not in my house not saw match i said as in general but i feel gk offence is much higher than outfield olayers as gk have his box area and gk king of that place and if he infiltrate he should get punished

If you watch any PL match may be 7-8 years back then you will realize how protected the GK's were.Rory Delap's throw in from sideline has led to direct goals on couple of occasions because the oger like defenders of Stoke City used to sit on top of the GK barely allowing them to move.That was all acceptable for English referees at that point of time.

 

[iDJ]

Power was not in my house not saw match i said as in general but i feel gk offence is much higher than outfield olayers as gk have his box area and gk king of that place and if he infiltrate he should get punished

Search on twitter. Links are not posting on forum.

 

[somnath chakraborty]

Search on twitter. Links are not posting on forum.

Yup just checked 50-50 not very hard as a tackle yes is ok

 

[rohitvatsa]

Pep every season after he won title tried to refresh the squad at his various clubs.This ssn. at City except Doku and to some extent Gvardiol none of the new signings have worked till now.Kovacic,Nunes were supposed to fill the void created by Gudagon's departure but they have been extremely poor.I still feel that with KDB coming back by the end of month there are chances of a City title charge.

Again proven right

 

[somnath chakraborty]

Again proven right

Now city should sack pep and united should grab him

 

[iDJ]

Yup just checked 50-50 not very hard as a tackle yes is ok

But he clearly denied the goal. Crystal Palace would've won if not for that tackle.