Discussion ICC Cricket World Cup 2019 | Champion - England

[Sparker0i]

In the next match for me Shankar shouldn't be in playing XI. Instead of him Pant or Karthik is better choice.

Shankar didn't bowl today because the margins were tight. With that point even the part time Kedar Jadhav didn't bowl either. If we have a good total on hand, teen these 2 will surely bowl and thus they must stay

 

[somnath chakraborty]

 

[Mystique]

Okay then Dhoni too giving useful suggestions today. I dont know how many of them watched this scene if not please watch in hotstar. The ball before Nabi was out by Shami, Dhoni came and gave some useful advice to Shami.

Akash chopra also gives nice suggestions , that doesn't mean he should be included in team

 

[ashokkumar675]

Don't know why so much blaming only for MSD. Rohit also got out below 10. But nobody blamed him. It seems if India lose Dhoni is the main reason. Don't drag previous history here.. If Rohit scored 2 100s , Dhoni also won World cup for India( Achievement). This shows so much NEGATIVITY in some members mind. As an Indian Fan I accept it was not his Day But he is definitely played better than Rohit( 2 Day) at least he scored some valuable Runs. And these runs were reason for INDIA s narrow win.
Don't compare Rohit and Dhoni. He is openner and other one is Finisher. So he will face more balls with less pressure when compared to Finisher. Also He is the best wicket keeper available in the whole world. For the same reason he is fit to play for India.

 

[Sagar]

Shankar didn't bowl today because the margins were tight. With that point even the part time Kedar Jadhav didn't bowl either. If we have a good total on hand, teen these 2 will surely bowl and thus they must stay

Check his previous stats he never completed his 10 overs. If you gave him chance as an all rounder then Jadeja is far better than him. At least Jadeja can field better than him & can save runs in the field.

 

[Sparker0i]

Check his previous stats he never completed his 10 overs. If you gave him chance as an all rounder then Jadeja is far better than him. At least Jadeja can field better than him & can save runs in the field.

But Jadeja won't bat at 4. Plus batting will look destabilized if Shankar is dropped

 

[Ashok L]

That's what I am saying whenever we need Dhoni to rescue we need him to at least play at 80+ strike rate considering his 300+ ODI experience. Today he was not even trying to hit the ball.

Accept or not he is not old Dhoni.

P. S. : I am not a Dhoni hater but I don't like their lovers always giving all the credit to him when team wins but not when team loose.

Hopefully we will able to see wintage MS from next innings.

See Rushil Bro, Today's Dhoni played like test cricket and he didn't recovered India and everything. But today his day was bad but for one mistake you guys bashing him like somewhat. Yeah today when top orders failed he should have rescued them but failed. But we cant simply blame or neglect them for a single mistake. Even Shankar didn't performed well last few matches (includes IPL) but he was again given a chance. Likewise today his performance was bad but you guys bashing him like anything to retire from cricket or drop him from team etc.,

 

[Mystique]

Don't know why so much blaming only for MSD. Rohit also got out below 10. But nobody blamed him. It seems if India lose Dhoni is the main reason. Don't drag previous history here.. If Rohit scored 2 100s , Dhoni also won World cup for India( Achievement). This shows so much NEGATIVITY in some members mind. As an Indian Fan I accept it was not his Day But he is definitely played better than Rohit( 2 Day) at least he scored some valuable Runs. And these runs were reason for INDIA s narrow win.
Don't compare Rohit and Dhoni. He is openner and other one is Finisher. So he will face more balls with less pressure when compared to Finisher. Also He is the best wicket keeper available in the whole world. For the same reason he is fit to play for India.

That is because Rohit failed only in this match in last 3 games . While Dhoni scored 32 ,1 , and today's test knock 28(52) . All came in death overs . Other teams also have finishers like butler , Maxwell that hardly go for test knock . Dhoni has been given role of finisher which he has been playing since 2004. He isn't new player to fail . His hitting ability isn't nowhere as it used to be . And this could cost India heavy in upcoming important matches.

Please stop giving excuse of his world cup wins . Kapil Dev also won world cup that doesn't mean he should be in team today.

 

[Sagar]

But Jadeja won't bat at 4. Plus batting will look destabilized if Shankar is dropped

I just gave an example bro.

I still on my point Pant or Karthik will do better than him.

 

[Ashok L]

I am not fan of Dhoni But blaming a particular person repeatedly for a single issue without seeing his past records is bad. Looks like what's happening in corporate politics So I came in. I think its utterly waste to make you guys understand.