India Tour of South Africa - 2018

[Endgame]

Why all these talks about wicket keeping going on.
Before coming up with any Expert opinions (to everyone who criticizing Saha), keep in mind, if Saha wasn't there, India would have lost the test by Innings margin.

 

[Sai Jai]

keep in mind, if Saha wasn't there, India would have lost the test by Innings margin.

U mean 1st test bro ??

If means ur referring their batting or something else ??

 

[Parth11]

India vs South Africa: Parthiv Patel, KL Rahul Set To Play; Ishant Sharma May Replace Bhuvneshwar Kumar

1) Wriddhiman Saha and opener Shikhar Dhawan could be dropped

2) Ishant Sharma could be considered in place of Bhuvneshwar Kumar

3) Ajinkya Rahane's comeback look highly unlikely

Read More: India vs South Africa: Parthiv Patel, KL Rahul Set To Play; Ishant Sharma May Replace Bhuvneshwar Kumar – NDTV Sports

 

[Vijay Krish]

They must be mad dropping Saha who broke MS Dhoni's record of most dismissals in a test match (10 Catches) and Bhuvi who had very good test match both with the ball as well as bat. Ishant also deserves to play as someone needs to hold one end without leaking runs and Ishant is a master of that. But replacing Bhuvi might not be a good idea. Ashwin will have no scope with this bowling on this pitch so may be Ishant could come in place of Ash for this test. And for the future who ever among this 5 pace bowlers perfom consistently should get the nod when Ashwin or Jadeja comes in when the conditions are good for spinners.

 

[id_866]

They must be mad dropping Saha who broke MS Dhoni's record of most dismissals in a test match (10 Catches) and Bhuvi who had very good test match both with the ball as well as bat. Ishant also deserves to play as someone needs to hold one end without leaking runs and Ishant is a master of that. But replacing Bhuvi might not be a good idea. Ashwin will have no scope with this bowling on this pitch so may be Ishant could come in place of Ash for this test. And for the future who ever among this 5 pace bowlers perfom consistently should get the nod when Ashwin or Jadeja comes in when the conditions are good for spinners.

Saha keeping well but parthiv can bat well than saha.its good decision to include him.rohit sharma should get replaced by rahane

 

[Shivraj]

if india will win the toss today then i am going to subscribe Sony Ten channels

 

[TushShar]

I know that Saha is a good keeper but the 10 dismissals you are talking about were not very difficult chances..any keeper with experience would have easily done the same..Parthiv might be a better batsman than him..So I am in favour of incluaion

 

[Varunkfdd]

if india will win the toss today then i am going to subscribe Sony Ten channels

Then wait for first 2 day

 

[Shivraj]

Then wait for first 2 day

bro still toss not completed

 

[Sai Jai]

I know that Saha is a good keeper but the 10 dismissals you are talking about were not very difficult chances..any keeper with experience would have easily done the same..Parthiv might be a better batsman than him..So I am in favour of incluaion

Exactly

What saha done is can be done by any wicket keeper whats so spl in that just catching behind wickets its a keeper job so he just done it isn't it ??

On the other side what he done in batting

So it's not a sin to searching the alternative imo

Parthiv or DK should be in the squad untill unless we find a man like Mr.Cool