India tour of Australia 2018-19 | News & Updates

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sagar
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies: Replies 2,328
  • Views Views: Views 157,466
The problem in our mindset always looking a WK as batsman instead of his WK skills

Who will do keeping ?? Pant ?? Can u give gloves to him world cup matches after seeing dropping important catches in Australia test series??
Fact is a fact bro we are criticising Dhoni because we want our nation to win world cup players will come and go
And if u r saying Pant doing bad in keeping than Dhoni also gave away 7 to 8 runs in byes in last match itself
 
The problem in our mindset always looking a WK as batsman instead of his WK skills

Who will do keeping ?? Pant ?? Can u give gloves to him world cup matches after seeing dropping important catches in Australia test series??

And what is wrong with that ?? Wasnt Gilchrist , Sangakkara and currently jos buttler , mushi wicketkeeper batsmen ?? Or only team india / dhoni is exception ??
 
My honest opinion.

Dhoni's style is always to take the game deep. Earlier it used to work every single time, because even though he takes so many balls to score the initial runs, he had the ability to cover it up in the end with his big hitting ability. But now, he seems to have lost that ability. I think It's better he changes his approach and follow a hit-out or get-out method, he did this in IPL 2018 and it paid off well. But again T20s are different, in ODIs it may or may not work. For example, if he started the big hitting in the first ODI when the scorecard was reading 4-3 and got out cheaply and the score reads 20-4, I'm sure India would have been bundled out below 150. So he might have been right in playing too slow in that situation. But, whether or not he would have covered up the strike rate had he not been given out wrongly is another point. He might or might not have, we will never know.

And about WC, I think it's too late to drop him from the squad. If they had to drop him, they should have done it at least before an year. And also there's no other wicket keeper equivalent to him right now except Saha (Not available). And Dhoni's experience in playing in big tournaments will come in handy at some point in the World Cup! For now, there's no option, but he needs to hang up his boots after World Cup, and knowing Dhoni he'll be doing that himself!!

Just another point, Even if you take Rohit Sharma, he starts at snail pace, but he has this tremendous six hitting skill which enables him to cover up the strike rate at the end. He's following this approach for almost an year now and has been tremendously successful in white ball cricket, especially ODIs.
 
My honest opinion.

Dhoni's style is always to take the game deep. Earlier it used to work every single time, because even though he takes so many balls to score the initial runs, he had the ability to cover it up in the end with his big hitting ability. But now, he seems to have lost that ability. I think It's better he changes his approach and follow a hit-out or get-out method, he did this in IPL 2018 and it paid off well. But again T20s are different, in ODIs it may or may not work. For example, if he started the big hitting in the first ODI when the scorecard was reading 4-3 and got out cheaply and the score reads 20-4, I'm sure India would have been bundled out below 150. So he might have been right in playing too slow in that situation. But, whether or not he would have covered up the strike rate had he not been given out wrongly is another point. He might or might not have, we will never know.

And about WC, I think it's too late to drop him from the squad. If they had to drop him, they should have done it at least before an year. And also there's no other wicket keeper equivalent to him right now except Saha (Not available). And Dhoni's experience in playing in big tournaments will come in handy at some point in the World Cup! For now, there's no option, but he needs to hang up his boots after World Cup, and knowing Dhoni he'll be doing that himself!!

Just another point, Even if you take Rohit Sharma, he starts at snail pace, but he has this tremendous six hitting skill which enables him to cover up the strike rate at the end. He's following this approach for almost an year now and has been tremendously successful in white ball cricket, especially ODIs.

Very well said bro . Nobody wants dhoni out of team but he himself should think about his play. Gone those days when we used to see Dhoni's big sixes . Now he is merely rotating strike like 7- 8th no batsmen . The best way of using dhoni is on 4th position between 11-40 overs . Even rohit also said so 👇
Dhoni batting at number four is ideal - Rohit - Cricbuzz
A absolutely agree with rohit . We need dhoni on 4th to rotate strike and big hitters on 5th and 6th number .
 
Very well said bro . Nobody wants dhoni out of team but he himself should think about his play. Gone those days when we used to see Dhoni's big sixes . Now he is merely rotating strike like 7- 8th no batsmen . The best way of using dhoni is on 4th position between 11-40 overs . Even rohit also said so 👇
If that's the case, team should not have tried so many players for that position in the past year. They instead should have used Dhoni there and nurture players who can close games at 6,7 positions. They have tried many players and finally decided that Rayudu is the best fit for number 4 from the available resources. They can't use Rayudu anywhere else now if Dhoni comes at 4, and he has to be dropped. This can put WC prospects in jeopardy!! Anyway, I think with current team combination, WC win seems far fetched. England is looking too strong and even New Zealand and South Africa are looking good.

I agree that the team needs to utilize Dhoni in the best way possible. And it's very difficult right now to find out exactly what that is. Sad but true.
 
If that's the case, team should not have tried so many players for that position in the past year. They instead should have used Dhoni there and nurture players who can close games at 6,7 positions. They have tried many players and finally decided that Rayudu is the best fit for number 4 from the available resources. They can't use Rayudu anywhere else now if Dhoni comes at 4, and he has to be dropped. This can put WC prospects in jeopardy!! Anyway, I think with current team combination, WC win seems far fetched. England is looking too strong and even New Zealand and South Africa are looking good.

I agree that the team needs to utilize Dhoni in the best way possible. And it's very difficult right now to find out exactly what that is. Sad but true.

Problem with team management is that they are under burden of Dhoni's world Cup winning greaness .even nobody dares to talk about his form openly be it former players or commentators , taking some measures about this is far fetched. They didn't experiment dhoni on 4th place whole year and kept trying other players . Somehow settled with rayadu afterall

And why rayadu cant play on 5th - 6th position ??
He can score quickfire runs .
 
Back
Top Bottom